SqlAgent not Capturing Errors from Powershell

Some strange behavior I noticed with sql server agent not capturing thrown errors from powershell.  Take this code:

try{
    1/0
}
catch{
    Write-Output ($_ | fl -Force | Out-String)
    throw "failure"
}

This will most certainly error, and if you run it in powershell, yep:

Right then, let’s call it from an agent job then via cmd line:

Looks good.  Let’s run it!

Uhhh….mkay….let’s check the history of said ‘successful’ job:

I certainly see the exception.  Why is the job returning successfully?

The answer?   

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

But, I do know how to get it to start throwing errors successfully.  The problem is with the –file argument to powershell in the command:

  Remove that, and viola:

Job now shows as failed: